A witch terrified — and enchanted — a prominent family in 19th century Tennessee.

A few hours outside Las Vegas, there’s a truly unique — and kind of alarming — motel.

Lake Champlain is home to North America’s most famous aquatic cryptid.

In rural North Carolina, there’s a circle of earth where nothing grows.

For many years, residents of Montana have known: there are rumors of a monster lurking in Flathead Lake.

It’s a psychic horse, Strangers. The premise sells itself.

The Exeter Vampire panic is more complex, and perhaps distorted, than we’ve been led to believe.

In the woods of Maine, rumors of an uncatchable, immortal beast have circulated for well over a century.

Mill Race parkgoers in Columbus, Indiana were probably not expecting to come face-to-face with a Bigfoot. But then again, who ever is?

We can all agree that moving is no fun. But add ghosts, and it gets a whole lot worse.

Whether presented as urban legend, murderous maniac, or ghostly avenger, the Bunnyman of Virginia has haunted a certain overpass for more than fifty years.

Perhaps it’s not the best-known cryptid, but the Michigan Dogman has crept across the Midwest’s imagination.

A mannequin with human hair became a doll, and lifelong companion and/or scapegoat.

In celebration of our new premium format, we’re sharing this premium episode with all listeners.

The Gulf Breeze UFO Sightings are among the most infamous in US extraterrestrial canon.

South Florida’s Coral Castle is a marvel of human creativity, talent and engineering.

In the 1940s, two Midwest families faced the same bizarre circumstance: unexplained fires.

In 1973, CB radio enthusiasts all over the U.S. — and apparently, the world — heard the panicked transmissions of a little boy in danger.

A rural Ohio family comes face-to-face--or maybe it’s fur-to-fur--with the Midwest’s most infamous version of Bigfoot.

Throughout the history of conventional archeology, artifacts have been found that seem to defy what we know about what we know.